Virtual reception

Review of appeals: 2021

4,901
Appeals received

including 493 duplicates; 107 at personal and field receptions by the management

245
Resolved positively
1,163
Satisfied through legal advice and explanations
117
Found anonymous

Summary of the review

The Anti-Corruption Agency is carrying out large-scale work aimed at protecting the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, at establishing a dialogue between officials and the population, and at bringing the work with appeals to a qualitatively new level based on the principle ‘It is not the people should serve the government agencies, but the government agencies should serve the people’.

In particular, in 2021, the Agency received a total of 4,901 appeals (493 duplicates), of which 107 were received during personal and field receptions of the Director of the Agency.

Of the appeals received:

  • 245 were resolved positively
  • 1,163 were satisfied with legal advice and clarifications
  • on 5 appeals with a positive decision, the Agency received letters of thanks
  • consideration of 2 was terminated at the request of applicants
  • 117 found anonymous
  • 43 taken into account
  • consideration of 158 was terminated in the prescribed manner due to their duplication.

Based on the results of consideration of appeals, 213 of them were submitted to the relevant ministries and departments, regional (district, city) administrations, as well as 53 statutory notices on the elimination of offenses and 13 warnings.

Moreover, based on the results of consideration of appeals, 52 decisions made in violation of the law, including 22 tenders, were canceled. According to the documents submitted by the Agency, law enforcement agencies initiated 15 criminal cases, 38 cases of administrative liability and 15 cases of bringing to disciplinary liability, as well as measures were taken to eliminate existing shortcomings.

The content of most of the appeals received by the Agency is related to the problems in the judicial branch, the actions of officials and corruption cases in various areas.

Outcomes

Number of appeals by outcome. The bar helps compare the values.

Outcomes, 2021
OutcomeAppealsComparison
Resolved positively245
— of which the Agency received thanks5
Satisfied through legal advice and explanations1,163
Left without consideration at the applicants’ request2
Found anonymous117
Taken for information43
Consideration of repeated appeals closed158

Action taken

Following the study of appeals.

213
Enquiries to ministries, agencies and khokimiyats
53
Submissions to remedy violations of the law
13
Warnings
52
Decisions contrary to the law cancelled

of which tenders: 22

15
Criminal cases opened
38
Administrative liability cases
15
Disciplinary liability cases

Appeals by sector

The ten most frequent subjects. The full list is below the table.

Appeals by sector, 2021
Sector, subjectAppealsShareComparison
Disagreement with court decisions63512.8%
On cases regarding the behavior of employees and offenses in the field of education4819.8%
On non-allocation of a land plot, land disputes and land plundering3467.1%
Disagree with the actions and decisions of law enforcement officials3437.0%
Disagreement with the decisions of the prosecutor’s office and unresolved appeals to the prosecutor’s office3036.2%
Disagreement with the actions of the heads of certain economic management bodies2695.5%
Dissatisfaction with illegal actions and decisions of officials and employees of local authorities2224.5%
On cases of violations in the process of public procurement and tenders1873.8%
Complaints about credit issues and actions of bank employees1533.1%
Disagreement with the actions of the officers of the Compulsory Enforcement Bureau and non-execution of enforcement documents1503.1%
All sectors and subjects (40)
All sectors and subjects (40)
Sector, subjectAppealsShare
Disagreement with court decisions63512.8%
On cases regarding the behavior of employees and offenses in the field of education4819.8%
— Public education (141 duplicates)386
— Higher and secondary specialized education53
— Preschool education41
On non-allocation of a land plot, land disputes and land plundering3467.1%
Disagree with the actions and decisions of law enforcement officials3437.0%
Disagreement with the decisions of the prosecutor’s office and unresolved appeals to the prosecutor’s office3036.2%
Disagreement with the actions of the heads of certain economic management bodies2695.5%
Dissatisfaction with illegal actions and decisions of officials and employees of local authorities2224.5%
On cases of violations in the process of public procurement and tenders1873.8%
Complaints about credit issues and actions of bank employees1533.1%
Disagreement with the actions of the officers of the Compulsory Enforcement Bureau and non-execution of enforcement documents1503.1%
On cases of labor law violations1372.8%
On problems in the field of housing and communal services1232.5%
On illegal constructions1212.5%
On cases of violations in the health sector and inappropriate behavior of medical workers1182.4%
On cases of fraud1082.2%
Dissatisfaction with the actions of heads and workers of citizens’ assemblies in communities861.9%
On employment in the Agency781.6%
Proposals for improving legislation691.4%
On compensation for material damage611.2%
On problems with gas supply541.1%
On cadaster issues521.1%
Regarding personal receptions of senior officials (26 of which are duplicates)491.0%
On cases of embezzlement of state budget funds481.0%
On problems in granting pensions and social benefits450.9%
Disagreement with the actions of employees of the State Tax Inspectorate430.9%
On landscaping issues190.4%
For non-compliance with the terms of the contract170.3%
On religious issues160.3%
Requests for practical assistance in recovering damages from natural disasters150.3%
On power supply problems120.2%
On the actions of lawyers110.2%
On environmental issues80.2%
On entrepreneurship issues170.3%
On problems with drinking water supply60.1%
On obtaining a passport50.1%
On the payment of dividends40.1%
Dissatisfaction with the actions and decisions of customs officers40.1%
On election issues40.1%
On insurance issues30.1%
Other issues4799.8%

Appeals by region

Number of appeals from each region.

Appeals by region, 2021
RegionAppealsComparison
Tashkent city1,088
Navoi region480
Kashkadarya region451
Surkhandarya region426
Tashkent region418
Namangan region391
Samarkand region373
Khorezm region239
Fergana region237
Bukhara region225
Jizzakh region225
Andijan region151
Republic of Karakalpakstan107
Syrdarya region86
From foreign citizens4

Conclusions and measures

Taking into account the importance of developing proposals and identifying appropriate measures to further improve legislation based on the elimination of factors that generate corruption and solve problems, the Agency approved an Action Plan 2022. In accordance with this Action Plan, tasks for 2022 are defined for the development and submission to the relevant authorities of draft regulatory legal acts to introduce amendments and additions to the current legislation.

All appeal reports